Online Exclusive Article

Comparison of Body Composition Assessment Methods in Breast Cancer Survivors

Claudio Battaglini

Fiona Naumann

Diane Groff

Edgar Shields

A. C. Hackney

Jeffrey M. Peppercorn

adiposity, breast cancer, breast neoplasms, breast cancer survivors
ONF 2011, 38(4), E283-E290. DOI: 10.1188/11.ONF.E283-E290

Purpose/Objectives: To examine and compare the reliability of four body composition methods commonly used in assessing breast cancer survivors.

Design: Cross-sectional.

Setting: A rehabilitation facility at a university-based comprehensive cancer center in the southeastern United States.

Sample: 14 breast cancer survivors aged 40-71 years.

Methods: Body fat (BF) percentage was estimated via bioelectric impedance analysis (BIA), air displacement plethysmography (ADP), and skinfold thickness (SKF) using both three- and seven-site algorithms, where reliability of the methods was evaluated by conducting two tests for each method (test 1 and test 2), one immediately after the other. An analysis of variance was used to compare the results of BF percentage among the four methods. Intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was used to test the reliability of each method.

Main Research Variable: BF percentage.

Findings: Significant differences in BF percentage were observed between BIA and all other methods (three-site SKF, p < 0.001; seven-site SKF, p < 0.001; ADP, p = 0.002). No significant differences (p > 0.05) in BF percentage between three-site SKF, seven-site SKF, and ADP were observed. ICCs between test 1 and test 2 for each method were BIA = 1, ADP = 0.98, three-site SKF = 0.99, and seven-site SKF = 0.94.

Conclusions: ADP and both SKF methods produce similar estimates of BF percentage in all participants, whereas BIA overestimated BF percentage relative to the other measures. Caution is recommended when using BIA as the body composition method for breast cancer survivors who have completed treatment but are still undergoing adjuvant hormonal therapy.

Implications for Nursing: Measurements of body composition can be implemented very easily as part of usual care and should serve as an objective outcome measure for interventions designed to promote healthy behaviors among breast cancer survivors.

Jump to a section


    Aleman-Mateo, H., Huerta, R.H., Esparza-Romero, J., Mendez, R.O., Urquidez, R., & Valencia, M.E. (2007). Body composition by the four-compartment model: Validity of the Bod Pod for assessing body fat in Mexican elderly. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 61, 830-836. doi:10.1038/sj.ejcn.1602597
    Bentzur, K.M., Kravitz, L., & Lockner, W.D. (2008). Evaluation of the Bod Pod for estimating percent body fat in collegiate track and field female athletes: A comparison of four methods. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 22, 1985-1991.
    Denmark-Wahnefried, W., Rimer, B.K., & Winer, E.P. (1997). Weight gain in women diagnosed with breast cancer. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, 97, 519-529. doi:10.1016/S0002-8223(97)00133-8
    Denmark-Wahnefried, W., Winer, E.P., & Rimer, B.K. (1993). Why women gain weight with adjuvant chemotherapy for breast cancer. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 11, 1418-1429.
    Erselcan, T., Candan, F., Saruhan, S., & Ayca, T. (2000). Comparison of body composition analysis methods in clinical routine. Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism, 44(5-6), 243-248. doi:10.1159/000046691
    Fuller, N.J., Jebb, S.A., Laskey, M.A., Coward, W.A., & Elia, M. (1992). Four-component model for the assessment of body composition in humans: Comparison with alternative methods and evaluation of the density and hydration of fat-free-mass. Clinical Science, 82, 687-693.
    Ginde, S.R., Geliebter, A., Rubiano, F., Silva, A.M., Wang, J., Heshka, S., & Heymsfield, S.B. (2005). Air displacement plethysmography: Validation in overweight and obese BCSs. Obesity Research, 13, 1232-1237. doi:10.1038/oby.2005.146
    Herber, D., Ingles, S., Ashley, J.M., Maxwell, M.H., Lyons, R.F., & Elashoff, R.M. (1996). Clinical detection of sarcopenic obesity by bioelectrical impedance analysis. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 64(3, Suppl.), 472S-477S.
    Heyward, V.H. (1998). Practical body composition assessment for children, adults, and older adults. International Journal of Sports Nutrition, 8, 285-307.
    Heyward, V.H. (2006). Advanced fitness assessment and exercise prescription (5th ed.). Champaign, IL: Human Kinetics.
    Isenring, E., Bauer, J., Capra, S., & Davies, P.S. (2004). Evaluation of foot-to-foot bioelectrical impedance analysis for the prediction of total body water in oncology outpatients receiving radiotherapy. European Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 58, 46-51. doi:10.1038/sj.ejcn.1601744
    Jackson, A.S., & Pollock, M.L. (1985). Practical assessment of body composition. Physician and Sports Medicine, 13, 76-90.
    Jackson, A.S., Pollock, M.L., Graves, J.E., & Mahar, M.T. (1988). Reliability and validity of bioelectrical impedance in determining body composition. Journal of Applied Physiology, 64, 529-534.
    Kroenke, C.H., Chen, W.Y., Rosner, B., & Holmes, M.D. (2002). Weight, weight gain, and survival after breast cancer diagnosis. Journal of Clinical Oncology, 23, 1370-1378. doi:10.1200/JCO.2005.01.079
    Kushner, R.F., Schoeller, D.A., Fjeld, C.R., & Danford, L. (1992). Is the impedance index (ht/2R) significant in predicting total body water? American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 56, 835-839.
    Pineau, J.C., Guihard-Costa, A.M., & Bocquet, M. (2007). Validation of ultrasound techniques applied to body fat measurement. A comparison between ultrasound techniques, air displacement plethysmography, and bioelectrical impedance versus dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry. Annals of Nutrition and Metabolism, 51, 421-427. doi:10.1159/000111161
    Rock, C.L., & Denmark-Wahnefried, W. (2002). Can lifestyle modification increase survival in women diagnosed with breast cancer? Journal of Nutrition, 132(11, Suppl.), 3054S-3057S.
    Rooney, M., & Wald, A. (2007). Interventions for the management of weight and body composition changes in women with breast cancer. Clinical Journal of Oncology Nursing, 11, 41-52. doi:10.1188/07.CJON.41-52
    Sardinha, L.B., Lohman, T.G., Teixeira, P.J., Guedes, D.P., & Going S.B. (1998). Comparison of air displacement plethysmography with dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry and three field methods for estimating body composition in middle-aged men. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 68, 786-793.
    Siri, W.E. (1956). The gross composition of the body. In C. Tobias & J. Lawrence (Eds.), Advances in biological and medical physics. New York, NY: Academic Press.
    Wagner, D.R., Heyward, V.H., & Gibson, A.L. (2000). Validation of air displacement plethysmography for assessing body composition. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 32, 1339-1344. doi:10.1097/00005768-200007000-00023
    Zhang, J.J., Jacob, T.J., Valverde, M.A., Hardy, S.P., Mintenig, G.M., Sepúlveda, F.V., … Higgins, C.F. (1994). Tamoxifen blocks chloride channels. A possible mechanism for cataract formation. Journal of Clinical Investigation, 94, 1690-1697. doi:10.1172/JCI117514